Sunday, July 20, 2008

The politics of War - UCSD lecture podcast review

Lectures do not always go well on podcast, but when the content is good enough, the drawbacks are sufficiently compensated for. The lectures UCSD puts in podcast come with additional disadvantages, that you have to take, in case you want to enjoy the quality of content. For one, get them quickly; as soon as the course is over, the podcasts will be discarded. Second: UCSD records the podcasts (apparently) automatically, which is maybe easy on the lecturer, but the system records if the lecturer doesn't speak, or starts and stops when programmed to do so, even if the lecturer operates in another window. You will find substantial pauses, sudden starts, empty podcasts and lengthy silences at the beginning and end of the podcast. So be it.

In spite of it all, I find myself persistently listening to the course Politics and Warfare by professor Victor Magagna (feed). This is a political science course which discusses various political theories of war and evaluates their strength in explaning how war starts, how it develops and what decides its outcome. Magagna distinguishes institutional theories on the one hand and structural, realist and neo-realist of the other. To put it very simply, institutional theories carry among their assumptions that war is basically never the best option whereas the other theories claim that there can be situations where war is the rational way to go.

I was drawn in, by the lengthy analysis of these theories adapted onto historic examples, most notably World War I (with the ever returning question who started it), but also the American War of Independence and the wars between the France of Louis XIV and the Dutch. This links in with the knowledge I acquired from history podcasts such as Berkeley's History 5, Stanford's The History of the International System, American History before 1870 and Historyzine. Because I felt familiar with the historic facts, I could get deeply engaged in the evaluation of political theory.

Relevant other posts:
History 5 on World War I,
The History of the International System,
A century of geopolitics - podcast review,
American History before 1870,
Historyzine.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

This is a terrific podcast! Thanks for bringing my attention to it. Looking forward to finishing it. :)

Anne the Man said...

So am I.
I wish UCSD would put in some basic editing. These lectures are cast in mp3's that last nearly three hours. But my estimate is that the effective lecture takes less than 90 minutes.

Anonymous said...

The dead air (sometimes for two hours) is rather annoying, but I find the chalkboard noises kind of hypnotic. :D

Anne the Man said...

Now do you? Old-school nostalgia?

Anonymous said...

I had the privilege to be in two of Prof. Magagna's courses and it was my best undergraduate experience. I wish more UCSD lecturers would have the same, or near, passion and knowledge that Prof. Magagna posses. I hope UCSD podcast his other courses.

Anne the Man said...

UCSD posted Magagna's course about East Asia philosophy, but as things go with UCSD, the course has been taken off-line, the day the season ended. Which was a matter of days after Magagna's last lecture.

Anne